Margaret M. Moree
Director of Workforce Development and Training
New York State Department of Labor
State Campus, Building 12
Albany, New York 12240
Dear Ms. Moree:
I am writing to express my concern about the conflict between the state of New York and the Amish whose young community members are being kept out of the work force. I understand that child labor laws are in place to protect the interests of children and keep them from being exploited, but I also believe that there are instances where exceptions should be made, or legislation should be changed.
In an established community like that the Amish people have, it seems fit that they should be allowed to carry on in whatever manner has worked for them over the years regarding schooling and work, providing there is not overwhelming evidence that their way of life is causing its citizens great harm.
It was not that long ago in our nation’s history that young people grew up learning and practicing the skills they would need in real life. In the book Johnny Tremain we read about a fourteen year old silversmith’s apprentice. This book is required reading for many young kids who are forced to sit in a classroom until they are good and ready for all the safe and appropriate jobs out there. Cookie cutter legislation does not make much sense to me. If there are people willing and eager to teach children skilled trades and how to be active in their communities, I don’t think the state should stand in their way.
Truly,
Liz Mann
